Renaldi`s Pizzeria in Canal Winchester

Our experience went like this: driving home from spring break and looking for great pizza, googled this and saw great reviews by locals. Having worked at a pizza place owned by Italians myself I am a great judge of pizza.The pizza gets a 4/5 because the sauce has no flavor(sorry guys)It's loaded with toppings! Thick and sought crust with a crispy edge.But you need better sauce and maybe some homemade ingredients like sausage or local meats/veggies.Service gets a 3/5 because all the workers were in the back. The owner talked to another local but didn't come out and talk to us in the 40 minutes that we were here.Clean, delicious, and a tad expensive. 4/5.Good luck on your expansion! Can't wait to come back again.

I had this once before but it was a while ago. We wanted something different so we used Door dash and had this delivered. Everything was super hot. So kudos to Doordash and Renaldi's for keeping everything nice and hot. The pizza (all the way) was excellent and cooked to perfection. The crust is a medium build with nice fluffiness but some crunch to go with it. Sauce was great as well and all the toppings completed it. We also ordered an Italian Sub and it to was simply amazing. I highly recommend Renaldi's Pizzeria. Please hit the the Like Button if this was helpful.

Pizza is pretty good and service is always on point.

Great pizza, and good service

Awesome little pizza shop. Lots of cheese, not overly saucy, and great prices. Few seats inside.

We came in just before 9:00pm rang the bell and waited 10min and saw zero people before I had to walk around the back room/kitchen yelling “Hellooo!”. Finally someone came inside from the back door reaking if marijuana and apologized saying they were on their break. I get taking breaks but I shouldn’t have to search the entire building for an employee while you do that just to put in an order.

Best pizza & subs in Canal. I’m picky & they listen to special requests. Great quality ingredients. Dough & sauce are amazing.

Food poisoning from her beware

They have subs

Drove by and stopped to try it, don't judge the book by its cover, really good pizza!!!

Since we moved to Canal 2 years ago, Renaldi's is always our go to! It's constantly great and the service is stellar. The house pizza is great, a little spicy. We usually add in the chef salad with Italian, amazing! Their subs are fantastic as well! You can't go wrong!

Moved here a year ago. Really good hometown pizza!

This place is one of my favorites for special occasions. The service is always phenomenal and friendly. The food is amazing and even with the smaller portions we have never left wanting more.

Good pizza , Good fair price,Courteous staff, I'd rate it 5 star if it were a perfect world

Food is excellent service is excellent the owner is kind and cares about his customers I would highly recommend their food and I really love their subs

Great little mom and pop pizza shop. This is the go to place for pizza in canal, and they have great subs too!

When compared to Kingy's, this pizza is superior. However, if you get cheese, request extra sauce and the breadiness of this pizza really drowns out the sauce with regular pizza. Not a very good beer selection and its certainly designed for just a few diners with a heavy reliance on pickup/delivery. But, as far as the pie goes, it's the best the Canal area has to offer.

Super good pizza!!! Tried to go to Masseys and kingys on a Friday night but they were both packed. So instead took a detour over here. Pizza was great! Nice team to boot! I enjoy going to the other rwo as they have awesome pizza and are sports bars. That being said I'll return next time I just want to pick up a pie and take it home. Nice job here!

Stopped here in a whim. One of the best pizza's I've had! Dining area isn't too big, but still worth dropping in!

Great pie!

Great pizza! Canal has some great pizza places and this is one of them! Had a large pep and sausage and it was excellent

100% amazing pizza!!

Great pizza. Friendly service. Try the baked italian subs.

Pizza is the best. Haven't tried anything else yet. Pricey but worth it. None of that $5 cardboard tomato soup pizza.

Fantastic pizza! Best meatball hero (sub in Ohio) this side of Brooklyn.

Our family favorite pizza place, love the Renaldi's

Really good local pizza. We order from here almost once a week, and have never been disappointed.

Excellent service and food!

Great pizza, great service. Crispy crust, no problem. Chewy crust, no problem either. Really like the down home atmosphere

Our "Go-to" pizza place. Super consistent with quality and time.

I personally thought the Pizza was pretty good, it had a sweet sauce and good crust. One word of caution though, your wife and/or children might find the pepperoni a bit spicy.

Ordered large half mushroom and half groundbeef,family liked it crust was pretty good nice business, will eat there again

First time trying this pizzeria. Friendly staff, and quickly made for pick up. Ordered a simple pep pizza tonight, crust not think or thin, just perfect in my opinion - but kind of flavorless. Sauce was tasty though. Stringy cheese and spicy pepperoni. Will eat here again as an alternate to other pizza places around town.

taste good but we saw someone smoking it was a worker and he was blowing the smoke into the building

I've left most other Pizza places behind 🏆Love Renaldi Pizza. 🏆 Love the subs. 🏆Salads are Awesome 🏆 🏆. Hot Wings absolutely awesome 🏆🏆 Looking forward to trying other menu items

Really this review should be 3.5 stars, but I decided to round down instead of up. The pizza was okay, I just feel that the consistency is bad. Some slices of pizza had sauce and it seemed others had minimal, ruining the taste. This wouldn't be an issue if it was just one time, but I have had this problem three times.

Placed an order for delivery, they only use doordash now. The doordash driver (Keaton roberts) ate 2 pieces of my pizza. Kept calling to let renaldis know, so they could tape the boxes shut or do something, phone has been busy for the last 30 minutes.

Great sauce, good deals and tasty pizza

Great service, friendly staff, delicious pizza, it's a cold treat the next morning!

Great subs and pizza

Always good pizza

Consistently good! The have the best Italian and Meatball subs in the city (not town) the best in Columbus. Seriously!! Pizza is great too!

Pizza was great...came out hot and plenty of toppings. ..limited seats...

Great overall experience. Pizza is delivered on time, and the delivery girl is always friendly. They do an exceptional job loading up on toppings. Crust could use some flavor, but still an excellent choice for dinner!

One of the best restaurants! The attention to detail is amazing! The food is just like what the menu states. Everything is fresh and is delicious. We were well taken care of from our hostess and waiter.

Best meatball sub in not just Canal but in Columbus, Ohio! Love this place!

No drivers were available so I had to go pick up. Garlic Cheese bread was burnt.

Super friendly! Ordered a customized pizza and it was delicious. Owner is a great guy. Try it once, you’ll ditch chain restaurant pizza.

We order from Renaldi's once a week. We absolutely love everything they make. Their sausage is our favorite!

Excellent hole-in-the-wall pizza joint. Pizzas are a good medium crust with just the right balance of crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings. Great prices to boot! The model Columbus-style pizza!